Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: Omega2752

Reconciliation :
Is there hope? Can he change? How long to give it?

default

 ouchythishurts (original poster new member #87935) posted at 5:51 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

I did a previous post with more detail of the affair, but in short, my partner (male, 38) had an emotional affair (with female, 26) from around June to September this year. I (female, 40) discovered it by reading his diaries. Prior to this I had challenged what was going on in their ‘friendship/art collaboration’ and challenged why he was so checked out of our relationship, but I was repeatedly lied to and gaslit.

He was actually planning to propose to me the week after I read his journals so I'm very glad I read them when I did. There was a whole lot of compartmentalisation going on. We just bought our first house together (the affair happened between the offer being accepted and the purchase completing, which was four days before I read the diaries). I’ve said many times now that I really regret that we’ve bought the house, I feel defrauded given the situation. But he says he doesn’t regret it, he really wanted it, and he has offered me half the equity (he put in twice my deposit) if we split because he truly meant it to be our house. He says again and again and again he wants us to stay together and he can’t bear the thought of losing me and he wants to be the partner I deserve.

Since d-day, it’s been a huge struggle. He’s tried and tried but keeps slipping up. The first battle was that he would get defensive every time we discussed it, but he did work on that and was getting better. He’s even learned to acknowledge when he’s sinking into shame and just say so and ask for a pause rather than withdrawing. He’s bucked up and been really proactive with household stuff to take some of life’s burden off me. He’s been trying to arrange nice things for us to do. But emotionally, he’s just not been getting it at any depth. He says sorry an awful lot but it feels profoundly hollow cos he does and says careless things that hurt me again and again. I’m pretty sure he’s neurodivergent and really struggling to process everything and that that’s a factor, though definitely not an excuse.

He’d sent a cut off whatsapp start of October and blocked the OW on there but last Wednesday, she emailed him. I mostly believe she did think it was just a friendship and I don’t blame her for what happened. And her message was mostly fair and just to ask about some things related to an art project they did together, and asking if he wanted her to post a book back, but there were also hints of hurt and anger in the message and one thing I thought was unnecessary for her to include. I said let’s just leave it to discuss with our couples counsellor on Tuesday and decide what to do then. But my partner couldn’t leave it and he ended up saying to me that even though he knows it will hurt me and make me feel threatened and fearful and make me feel like he’s prioritising her feelings over mine, and even though he knows my wound is the biggest in all this, receiving the message had opened up his wound and he doesn’t feel he can heal ours until he’s healed theirs by discussing a few things and having a better ending with her. And that that shouldn’t be incompatible with our healing. To which I said I firmly disagree and that I’d like him to move to his mum’s for a bit.

I was actually open to one email response, crafted together, simply answering the reasonable questions, but hadn't told him this as I was waiting to discuss at couples therapy. But the way he said all that, clearly laying out all the risks to me, very much saying I know you have the biggest pain here but can you just wait a minute while I deal with mine and hers first… I just knew I had to get him out the house. I’ve been on a continuous cycle of hope and hurt from when I first challenged him on their relationship in July and I can feel the cortisol in my body from the continued stress, it’s been wrecking my physical and mental health. (Though I am managing, and I have a wonderful therapist, and though my friends weren’t great to begin with and seemed scared to talk about it, they’re showing up for me a lot more now).

I 100% get that some of you will think I’m delusional and mad to still want to reconcile, and I know this is probably part of the bargaining stage of grief. But I genuinely believe he loves me to the best of his ability. I think he’s stuck in limerence and affair fog and a total midlife crisis and guilt and shame and completely overwhelmed and unable to make sense of everything. And I think he has long been emotionally immature, and I think you need emotional maturity to have integrity and you need integrity to have a healthy and safe relationship. But I do not think he is a bad person; he has always been kind to me before, but he has also been very passive, and I think it’s passivity and secrecy and fear and immaturity that led to all this rather than deliberate cruelty. I even think his plea to resolve his and her pain first was more from him wanting everyone to be completely okay after all this and thinking those are easier to fix, but not realising/admitting that it doesn't work like that: pain in the fallout is gonna be there for all of us.

I did read in his diary (I have been super naughty and kept peeking since d-day) that he always forgets how much trauma I have and how vulnerable I can be because I am so competent and resilient and strong. And this chimes with how a lot of people treat me; I’m the one everyone leans on and I have created this myself, though have learned to show my vulnerability more in recent years, but I find people really struggle to see it and respond to it cos my strength and resilience is very real too. Not to blame myself, but I get why he thinks I can just hold all the pain while he sorts his first. It’s still shit and wrong though. But we have had that dynamic in our relationship a long time and I’ve co-created it with my caring, giving, nurturing tendencies and my self-sufficiency. Again, not blaming myself and absolutely not responsible for the affair and for his poor treatment, but just understanding the dynamics. Incidentally, any reconciliation will definitely need a move out of the parent-child dynamics we have had for a while and for him to be more responsive to my vulnerability.

Anyway. I initially booted him out just until Tuesday but then later asked for a month alone so that I can work on healing myself because he keeps spinning me out with his chaos and inconsistency. He left Friday and I do already feel much better. We haven’t talked about the details of living apart; boundaries, levels of communication etc. I’m waiting for couples therapy on Tuesday to address that. We've been sending messages and I've tried to keep it just to practical and non-emotional things, but it's hard to resist the desire to reach for him emotionally. But I also know that was keeping me on the hope/hurt seesaw cos sometimes he gives me what I need and other times he absolutely does not. So I need to start giving myself what I need and getting it elsewhere to recover myself.

85% of me thinks this separation will be a precursor to the end of our relationship. It’s the integrity thing. I can’t trust I won’t get hurt until his actions and words match up and they just haven’t been at all. He has an awful lot of work to do on himself.

But we had a beautiful relationship before. Not perfect, but lots of things about us really did work. And we’re both a bit quirky and unconventional; neither of us have many of the standard life aspirations, we both mostly enjoy nature and arts and living a more simple and fun life, rather than striving for luxury. We like the same niche stuff, have chilled and easy going temperaments, enjoy play and silliness, had a good sex life and were mutually mega affectionate which always gave me huge happiness. I think the affection compensated for emotional stuntedness cos I always felt loved by his body.

And there’s 15% of me that still hopes. That hopes through therapy he can turn himself around and sort himself out. Build up his self-esteem, work through the shame, get more clarity on his values, develop his capacity for empathy, learn to be more in touch with his own emotions and more curious about mine, figure out what to do with his life. Become a better partner. And he says he really wants that too, that it’s time he grows up and he can’t keep carrying on in life the way he is. He's only just, in the fallout of this, admitted to himself that he's probably neurodivergent and has started getting support for that so that should help.

Is there any hope? I don’t want people to bash him, even though there's good reason to. But I ideally want to hear from people whose WS managed to turn things around and grow up and be better people. How long does it take?? And will some time of separation help or hinder? And what boundaries during that time apart would be optimal?? I feel like we need no contact (aside from practical necessities) and to both focus on ourselves before we come back together, but man that feels hard. I want it though. But I also know I’ll be carrying a fantasy that we’ll reunite and he’ll have done enough work and snapped out of his limerence and shows signs of building up the qualities we both want him to develop.

I went to see the film Wicker today and found myself fantasising about new loves so I'm not completely down on the idea of separation. But I do love my partner and if we could work through this, it would be so good for both of us. I've been feeling angry at him most of today but when I returned from the cinema, he had popped back to the house to get more of his stuff, and he did quite a lot for me while here: like put up some outdoor lights he’d ordered, took the stinky bins out (I have a crazy sensitive sense of smell), did all the washing up, etc. He wasn’t great at being proactive with house stuff pre-affair but he has been since and he has shown lots of other signs that change is possible. It's just that it's all a bit surface level at the moment, but we are only just over two months out. Can it go deeper with more time? And how much time?

posts: 19   ·   registered: Nov. 6th, 2026   ·   location: UK
id 8909564
default

BackfromtheStorm ( member #86900) posted at 11:03 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

Friend nobody is judging you for wanting to try again, most here tried or are trying or succeed in reconciling with their wayward partner.

So don’t worry.

Here is the thing: there is no timeline or expectations for when to decide if to leave a cheating partner or not.

You must do what you feel is right and you want to, and to get clarity on where you stand you must heal from the trauma of betrayal first.

A word of caution is usually given about the cheater.

Nobody deserves a second chance. It’s an immense gift just considering to give it a try. Unfaithful people usually try to get away from betrayal because they fear consequences (they never think they’ll be caught or that they might suffer any consequence for adultery).

You giving a second chance is validation to your wayward partner that you still care, so it does soothe the shame of being found out.
Doesn’t mean they will or are even willing to change though.

That’s why before considering reconciliation you need to assess if this person is truly committed to change and become better.

For a false reconciliation is as painful if not more painful than the first betrayal.

You also sounded a little confused about what you want, this was my impression, as you are wondering about finding new loves.

That to me is a sign that you may feel the need to close this chapter of your life as your connection with this partner is for this or other reasons, compromised.

What do you truly feel you need?
Start looking inside for the answer. There is no correct one, only the felt one.

You are welcome to send me a PM if you think I can help you. I respond when I can.

posts: 1247   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2026   ·   location: Poland
id 8909574
default

Asterisk ( member #86331) posted at 11:19 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

Ouchythishurts,

Wow, 2 months out from an affair that happened while engaged and living together. To me, that is a huge red flag!

I am fully onboard with what Backfromthestorm has offered. I would like to share some thoughts as well.

(Note, I am a betrayed spouse who chose reconciliation and am 34 years post affair. It was the right decision for us but not for everyone or for every situation.)

Is there any hope?


Absolutely yes! But results you can trust won’t come easily or soon. Maybe 5 plus years from now, you might find healing and reconciliation. But many of those 5 plus years, if you follow the typical path will come with enormous pain. If you both stick it out and work hard, it might even be worth it. I know it was for me, but many have come to a different conclusion.

I don’t want people to bash him, even though there's good reason to. But I ideally want to hear from people whose WS managed to turn things around and grow up and be better people. How long does it take??


You will never hear me "bash" your partner. Some might, just understand pain speaks loud and harsh. I have often read here that if you approach recovery correctly, you might get there in about 5 to 7 years. It took my wife and I much longer and even then I had some unexpected ruminations, 33 years post D-day, that sent me spiraling down. I cannot stress it strong enough, it is a long, hard trudge and that is when both partners are fully in and dedicated to personal growth and change. Without that, well, not too likely.

And will some time of separation help or hinder?


In my opinion, yes separation is important but not necessary. I separated from my wife for 5 months moving 1200 miles away. I figured that if she wanted out, I gave her an easy exit. If she wanted to stay with me, she would have to leave the city she loved.

And what boundaries during that time apart would be optimal?? I feel like we need no contact (aside from practical necessities) and to both focus on ourselves before we come back together, but man that feels hard.


Yes boundaries are extremely important but what those are depends on you. Though we were separated by space my wife and I talked on the phone every day. As you stated, it was really hard. I have never been over weight and yet during that 5 months I lost 40lbs. I was gaunt. My friends and family did not know about the affair so many thought I had cancer.

I want it though. But I also know I’ll be carrying a fantasy that we’ll reunite and he’ll have done enough work and snapped out of his limerence and shows signs of building up the qualities we both want him to develop.


Be careful of the "fantasy". I was sorely tempted and am forever grateful that I did not take that route. Some betrayeds turned waywards here did and would be better fitted to address your fantasy thoughts. That said, perfectly normal.

One thing that I think you are doing that is, in my opinion, a mistake. A mistake that my wife and I did which contributed to our very long recovery time and that is going to couples therapy. That is needed but later in the process. What I believe is needed 1st is for the two of you to go for individual counseling. Your boyfriend has a broken part of himself that played a role in his decision to cheat. And as unfair as it is, you now probably have a broken part in you due to the affair. Maybe not, but I know I sure as heck did. Until those broken parts are delt with independently, successful couples therapy is highly doubtful.

I hope this helps. Take care of yourself and keep talking.

Asterisk

posts: 538   ·   registered: Jul. 7th, 2025   ·   location: AZ
id 8909577
default

 ouchythishurts (original poster new member #87935) posted at 6:39 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Thanks for your thoughts both, I really value them.

What do you truly feel you need?

I need secure love. To feel safe in a relationship with a partner who acts with care and protection towards me and who will try their best to avoid causing me pain. I want a partner whose words and actions align so that I can trust him. A partner who is curious and cares deeply about my internal emotional world and who also wants to share his with me. I want us both to have our independence and autonomy too, but to absolutely cherish togetherness and partnership and to not let anything else push that to breaking point.

And I’d like that with my partner. I wonder if our relationship may have almost been more like best friends and fuck buddies until now, rather than a truer partnership.

We’ve only been together five years. If it’ll take another five plus years of pain to get to the point I want, that doesn’t really feel like good life maths. I do know it will take time for all the change that’s needed, but I’d be willing to work alongside him for that if he could just get to a point where he’s not devastating me on an almost daily basis. He still doesn’t really get it; doesn’t get that he caused all this and that he needs to be responsible and accountable, and that it has hurt me in such a deep and guttural and core crushing way. I do have a lot of childhood abandonment, neglect and betrayal trauma that is no doubt multiplying the impact of this, but he’s always known that about me, so if he loves me he has to be able to accept those challenges too. And I know he can’t heal all of me and I’m responsible for that, but I just need him to stop hurting me and telling me my pain is bottom priority, while simultaneously telling me he loves me and desperately wants to heal our relationship and that he wants to change and be a better person.

I’ve been in IC many years. He just started a few weeks ago. But his therapist doesn’t seem to get the betrayal bit and wants to rescue him from his guilt by minimising it. Our couples therapist absolutely gets it and is really good at connecting with him; making him feel safe and understood but also holding him accountable. I don’t think she’d do this, but my ideal would be that she carries on with him individually until he’s made enough progress to not be so careless with my feelings, and then I rejoin to do the relationship work.

[This message edited by ouchythishurts at 6:41 AM, Monday, November 16th]

posts: 19   ·   registered: Nov. 6th, 2026   ·   location: UK
id 8909585
default

The1stWife ( Guide #58832) posted at 8:33 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

but I just need him to stop hurting me and telling me my pain is bottom priority, while simultaneously telling me he loves me and desperately wants to heal our relationship and that he wants to change and be a better person.

Objectively this is not a good sign.

For now I would strongly suggest you ignore his words and focus on his actions. His actions will tell you everything you need to know - what he thinks and feels is more obvious in his actions.

Taken from your post he

wants to change and be a better person.

What actions has he shown you since Dday shows you he means this? Helping with household chores is acting like he’s in the doghouse and trying to get out by "being nice sbd helpful".

While appreciated it is NOT making amends and helping you heal.

His insistence on speaking w/ the OW is telling. His needs come first based on his actions.

Survived two affairs and brink of Divorce. Happily reconciled. 12 years out from Dday. Reconciliation takes two committed people to be successful.

posts: 15889   ·   registered: May. 19th, 2017
id 8909589
default

 ouchythishurts (original poster new member #87935) posted at 9:00 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

I think in his mind, my pain is 8, his is 5 and hers is 2. And he’s essentially saying to me, can you just carry her 2 and 2 of mine, which will put her on zero so that’s one problem sorted, me on 3 which I think I can deal with and that’ll give me more capacity to focus on you. But he doesn’t realise that’ll put me on 12 which is way over my limit. And why the fuck do I have to carry all the pain?

And yet, I also know that if our couples therapist explained this to him, he would get it and do the right thing by me.

posts: 19   ·   registered: Nov. 6th, 2026   ·   location: UK
id 8909590
default

BackfromtheStorm ( member #86900) posted at 11:31 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

I need secure love.

That means you want secure attachment.
The fantasy about new loves might very well be a sign that your instincts are telling you "he is not it, not serious". Which like most gut feelings, you should trust if it’s the truth.

But also you have been betrayed, betrayal damages the attachment so even if you started with secure attachment you might be thrown off and need to recover before reclaiming it.

Some betrayed become cheaters themselves because their attachment is messed up to the point of becoming broken. Happens that the abused become the abuser after trauma.

Heal the trauma first.
For you.

To feel safe in a relationship with a partner who acts with care and protection towards me and who will try their best to avoid causing me pain. I want a partner whose words and actions align so that I can trust him. A partner who is curious and cares deeply about my internal emotional world and who also wants to share his with me. I want us both to have our independence and autonomy too, but to absolutely cherish togetherness and partnership and to not let anything else push that to breaking point.

To me personally that’s what a relationship is so how it should look like. If it deviates is either dysfunctional or there are serious issues to be addressed.

Better to quit or resolve those instead of sitting passively in it.

And I’d like that with my partner. I wonder if our relationship may have almost been more like best friends and fuck buddies until now, rather than a truer partnership.

I understand.
No you weren’t fuck buddies from your side, that’s rules I out.

Fuck buddies are friends who have clear boundaries, fun, sex and friendship, but it is clear and I. The open.

You were convinced you had a relationship.

He might or might not have seen you as fuck buddies, but more likely he manipulated you into feeling the safety of a relationship while planning and putting effort into backstabbing you.

He might also have felt "love" but a cheater has serious issues in loving themselves more often than not. And when you can’t do that you can’t truly fully love someone else.

It could be both, don’t assume the negative from what he feels (he doesn’t share right now the inner truth, not yet), but accept the negative that you suffered and emotional and sexual trauma from the abuse of infidelity from this guy.

That should take your full priority.
Not what he feels, what he could feel in the future.

Only what you feel and how you want to feel in the future.

Protect that.
You come first

You are welcome to send me a PM if you think I can help you. I respond when I can.

posts: 1247   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2026   ·   location: Poland
id 8909591
default

The1stWife ( Guide #58832) posted at 12:44 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

As someone who successfully and happily R, the first few years of R are not easy.

You don’t wake up one day and say "I’m healed". But you do wake up and realize today you are better than you were 1 year ago, 6 months ago, 4 weeks ago etc.

First off, you need to feel secure yourself before the cheater can add to your security. And that add’l security comes with the cheater showing consistency and integrity and accountability etc.

I remember the day (almost 3 years after Dday) that I realized I had to stop waiting to heal and heal myself. I had to stop doubting myself and trust myself more. I had to stop living in the past and constantly going over the events as though they happened last week.

And I had to have faith. Faith that no matter what, I would end up in a good place and happy.

I hope this helps you.

Survived two affairs and brink of Divorce. Happily reconciled. 12 years out from Dday. Reconciliation takes two committed people to be successful.

posts: 15889   ·   registered: May. 19th, 2017
id 8909593
default

 ouchythishurts (original poster new member #87935) posted at 1:31 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Thanks for your thoughts Backfromthestorm. I think what I meant by the best friends and fuckbuddies thing isn't that we don't mean a lot to each other, but that maybe that's been the style of our relationship, rather than a deeper partnership. His parents divorced when he was 4 and neither ever got in a relationship again. His mum's support all came from close friendships so that was the main model of relating he grew up with. My parents also divorced when I was 4, dad disappeared, mum got together with my ex-step-dad very soon after, and their relationship was super dysfunctional, constant shouting matches, stonewalling, controlling, both heavy drinkers, narcissistic tendencies, chaos generally. So neither of us have a model of a healthy romantic relationship and I think his best guess is close friendship + sex and maybe I've been comfortable with that because I fear the dysfunctional enmeshment that runs through my family. I think for a lot of our relationship, we've sort of done our own things alongside each other and it's worked pretty well in lots of ways. Though I have often not felt well supported, but thought that cos he wasn't abusive like my ex and like my parents, that that was fine and I can rely on therapists to provide the deeper emotional support I don't get from him. And on his side, I think he's just been in avoidance for all that time and not facing up to things, hence why his life is a bit of a shitshow at the moment (he's never really figured out a career but has run out of steam for meaningless jobs to pay the bills. He is passionate about his art, but it's hard to make money from. A lot of our friends have been more absent in recent years cos of babies, chronic illness, or moving away. And now he’s blown up our relationship, which he describes as the one bit of his life that was working.)

We got a bit rushed into buying the house cos our landlord was selling up, and maybe that's the first challenge that really required proper partnership. And instead of face it like a man, he ran away to someone else to pretend he was in his 20s again. And I think his plans to propose to me were adding to the pressure of inner conflict he had around becoming a proper grown up.

He definitely does have serious issues loving himself. This has all come from low self esteem and he wouldn't deny that.

And you're right, I absolutely have to focus on me and what I feel and what I need. That is why I'm asking for this month separation, to try and re-center myself cos I get really spun out by him. And though I try battle the codependency I learned in childhood, it's so ingrained that of course it comes out in such a crisis. I know that since d-day I've been trying to coach him into doing the right thing and have been really hypervigialant - of course I have; I'm not gonna criticise myself for that - but it's not been fully allowing him to process and respond in his own way and therefore not allowing me to fully see him. So the separation is to settle my nervous system but also to get out of the temptation for me to control, to avoid him hurting me again. (I feel like I was too anxious about being controlling before and that's what stopped me putting my foot down sooner about the ‘friendship’, so of course the temptation to control is amped up now).

Thanks for your comments to 1stwife. Can I ask how long it took your partner to start showing you that consistency and integrity and accountability etc? Cos if he could start showing up with that, I really do think we could heal. But I'm not seeing it so far. And I don’t think I can live in the same house as him until he starts showing it because the inconsistency wrecks my nervous system.

I have absolute faith in myself to heal and even grow from this, though I know it will take time. But I can’t do that if he’s living in the same house and re-traumatising me every few days. So either I live alone to do it, or he needs to show up with a lot more empathy and self awareness.

I think I have to recognise it will take time to get the answers I want. I need to take the pressure off myself to decide. Maybe I reassess after the month separation and see where I'm leaning then.

[This message edited by ouchythishurts at 1:58 PM, Monday, November 16th]

posts: 19   ·   registered: Nov. 6th, 2026   ·   location: UK
id 8909596
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy